top of page

When Your Marketing Feels Off: How to Tell If You've Outgrown Your Branding

Nov 11
6 min read
Black and white image of a man putting on a cap with a purple and blue gradient border. White text says "How to Tell If You've Outgrown Your Branding by Julia Duncan"

Key Takeaways


  • Rebranding starts with identity: A rebrand is necessary when an organization or individual's identity has evolved beyond what the current brand communicates.

  • Internal confusion is a warning sign: Misalignment among your team, tension between legacy and innovation, and struggles with marketing design can indicate your brand no longer fits.

  • Customer confusion signals a disconnect: If customers don't understand what you offer, recognize your personality, or connect with your marketing, your brand may need a refresh.

  • Looking and sounding like everyone else is a problem: Effective branding creates recognition and preference. If your brand feels generic, you're losing opportunities to stand out.

  • Choose a branding agency that prioritizes identity: The right partner will understand your history, explore your vision, ask thoughtful questions, and ground recommendations in reality.


"Rebrand." What a heavy word! It indicates growth while ushering in a sense of loss. It hails innovation while signaling the end of an era.


Not to mention, rebranding can be expensive! And if you've been in marketing for even a few years, you've witnessed at least one major rebrand controversy. (Our condolences to Cracker Barrel.)


A good brand evokes deep emotion in its customers, employees, and business partners. It creates recognition, builds trust and preference, and represents the identity of an organization or person. Choosing to change that representation requires a thoughtful approach and a deep understanding of your identity.



So, why do organizations and people rebrand?


There can be many explanations for why someone chooses to rebrand. They might say things like, "Oh, it looked outdated" or "It was time." Companies often rebrand after a merger or an acquisition. A public figure might rebrand after a scandal or change in opinion.


The explanations for "why" could be endless. But at the core, every necessary rebrand is about an underlying shift in identity. If your identity as a business or individual has changed, your brand needs to change too.


Rebranding is necessary when the identity of a person, product, or organization has changed, and the brand no longer accurately represents that identity.

We like to keep things practical around here, so let's dig in to some of the signs your brand is in need of a refresh. Because identity starts on the inside, we're going to go internal before we go external.


4 internal signs you need a rebrand



  1. There's confusion in the dugout

    Your team needs to be clear about who you are and what you're trying to accomplish. If I were to ask your staff what you organization is about, would I get a bunch of different answers? If yes, your identity is unclear internally and is almost guaranteed to be unclear externally as well.


    four frames of a woman thinking hard while equations drift over the images

    Now, I'm not talking about one person thinking you sell Easter candy and another thinking you sell spring treats. That's a different angle on the same mission. I'm talking about one person thinking you sell candy and another thinking you sell diet protein bars. Could it be a communication issue? Sure. But it might also be a branding issue.


  2. The "old guard" is at war with the "new"

    Before your mind leaps to intergenerational office wars, that's not what I'm talking about here. The battle between the old guard and the new guard is more legacy versus innovation than old versus young.


    When a brand experiences growth, tension can arise between those who remember and value what was, and those who look forward to and value what could be. A rebrand (if done well) can help your team honor what came before while making space for what is yet to come.


  3. Your marketing team struggles to make designs look good


    Your marketing team is a great place to start when deciding whether or not to rebrand. If they consistently struggle to make marketing designs look good despite being talented, they glaze over when you ask for something new, or they offer a weak "you're killin' me but I'll try" to design requests, the brand may not be working.


    "You're killin' me smalls" meme featuring Ham Porter from The Sandlot

    Straight up ask your marketers (or marketing agency/contractor) if they think it's time for a rebrand. I guarantee you, they have thoughts. If they don't, then you can ask me. (I'm not joking, message me on LinkedIn.)


  4. You keep thinking "gosh, that looks old" when you see your logo

    I know, I know. You and that logo have come a long way together. But if you keep flinching inside when you look at it because it reminds you of the early 2000s (and not in an intentional, nostalgic way), it could be a sign you need a rebrand.


    Your identity has hopefully aged along with your market. Unless your entire schtick is being retro and selling Y2K throwbacks, it's time to line your visual brand up with your current reality.


We could probably go on for days about the internal signs you need a rebrand. Brand identity starts on the inside, then flows outward. So what does it look like on the outside when you've outgrown your brand?


4 external signs you need a rebrand


  1. Your customers and clients are confused about what you do

    Confusion happens for a number of reasons. Maybe you've added or removed services, launched new products, or shifted your focus. It's not uncommon for offerings to outpace branding.


    Tom Holland's Spiderman saying "I'm so confused right now"

    Listen for customers saying things like, "Wait, what do you sell again?" or "I had no idea you offered ___________" when you've offered it for five years. These are all signs you've outgrown your current brand.


  1. Your marketing doesn't sound like you

    I don't mean your brand has to literally sound like you (the reader of this post). However, a good brand has its own voice and personality. Duolingo and Wendy's are popular examples, but you don't have to go that extreme.


    A plumbing brand might sound like a knowledgeable grandpa. A therapy brand might go for soothing yoga instructor. A wedding cake brand might opt for "bride's best friend." If your marketing has no personality or sounds like something you don't recognize (or like), it might be time for a rebrand.


  1. People aren't curious about what you do

    It's true, sometimes people aren't curious about what you do because they're not your target audience. That's completely okay. Not every brand is for everyone.


    However, if people who should be your clients struggle to connect with your work, there might be a branding mismatch. Pay attention to glazed over looks, furrowed brows, and other signs of "huh?" coming from your customers.


  1. You feel like a clone

    Ouch. But honestly, the struggle is real. The temptation to slip into corporate linguistic acrobatics or to simply ask your favorite AI chatbot to design or write the thing can be strong.


    An image of storm trooper clones from Star Wars

    The problem with looking and sounding like everyone else is that you look and sound like everyone else. (I know, so profound.) Remember, a good brand builds recognition and preference. You can't have that if you look and sound like any other person on the internet. If you find yourself in the clone zone, it's definitely time for a rebrand.


Of course, you might know of some signs we didn't mention. Odds are, if your gut is telling you the brand isn't working, you're probably right. But remember, a rebrand is fundamentally about your identity as an organization or individual. You don't just need a new logo—you need a new representation of your current reality.


What should you look for when hiring a branding agency for your rebrand?


There are so many branding agencies out there (and yes, many of them are excellent). Finding the right fit can be a bit challenging, so here are a few tips for what to look for when planning a rebrand.


Look for an agency that:


  • Takes the time to understand your history and previous brand iterations

  • Is deeply curious about where you're headed as an individual or organization

  • Asks thoughtful questions about your values, vision, and mission

  • Understands rebranding can be a deeply emotional process internally and externally

  • Grounds their recommendations in reality instead of fantasy


Doing identity work individually or as a business can be daunting but know it's worth it. Approaching a potential rebrand with thoughtfulness, a commitment to reality, and hope for the future will set you up for success.


Thinking it might be time for a rebrand?


We're a little obsessed with brand identity and authenticity in marketing. If you're considering a rebrand, we'd love to hear more about your project.





Explore our branding packages.

Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.
  • Instagram
  • White Facebook Icon
  • White LinkedIn Icon
  • Youtube
bottom of page